Reviews of the Barnes & Noble Nook start to surface.
December 7th, 2009 | Author: Tiffany
The official review from Engadget has made its way to the surface. Some quick quotes:
In our tests — and this may just be due to the Kindle we were using — we felt it very slightly outperformed Amazon’s option in contrast, though the Kindle has a considerably faster refresh rate when turning pages. In fact, the Nook’s refresh speed was sometimes a little annoying, with us actually having moments in between page turns of waiting for more content — not a feeling you want to encounter if you’re trying to mimic the book-reading experience.
In regards to navigation:
once you get the hang of the system it starts to make some sense, but it’s nothing we’d describe as intuitive, and your rhythm is thrown off by one major factor: the extremely sluggish response of the device. That’s right, you’re not zipping and zooming through any of these menus, you’re patiently waiting for the device to do its thing. That laggy scrolling we saw in the demo the day this was launched? Not really much better in the release version.
User Interface:
While the UI is different (not necessarily a bad thing in our eyes), there are also places where it is plain bad (necessarily a bad thing in our eyes). There’s instability to spare in the review unit we used. More than once we saw the familiar Android force close / wait message when trying to load a piece of the software up, and we encountered a lot of unexpected pauses and lag when trying to get through menus, causing a number of incorrect selections and general annoyance.
Conclusion:
when it came to day to day use, we felt let down in a big way, and can only imagine how magnified that feeling would be if we’d gone and shelled out nearly $300 for the device.
In the end, the Nook is an intriguing product launched by a powerful force in the world of booksellers, but the initial offering feels long on promises and short on delivery.
I can’t imagine that Barnes & Noble is having a very good day today. Additionally, it seems that Nooks are now not shipping until January, completely missing the holiday season – that can’t be good for them. They haven’t handled this release well, hopefully they can get it to together and give Amazon a run for their money…. then we all win 
After this posted, I stumbed upon more reviews:
CNET
Gizmodo
NY Times
All Things Digital
Consumer Reports
Business Week
Other posts you may like:
Tags: -
[...] Kindle Vixen upsold me to buy a Kindle as I’m “old school” and use my laptop to read ebooks. –> You can read her mad sales skillz here. [...]
Mockingjay (Hunger Games, #3) by Suzanne Collins
May 25, 2010
June 29, 2010
My name is Tiffany and I am enamored with all things Kindle. When I am not cuddled up with my Kindle I am raising 2 stubborn little girls while attending college full time. I enjoy reading paranormal romance, urban fantasy, and dark urban fantasy. I have recently branched out to include some sci-fi and romance (both m/m and contemporary). I love a good alpha male, no matter what genre he is from.
The Nook is $300 bucks???? Holy crapz, thats more than an iphone, unless I was reading the conclusion incorrectly.
@K.C. I think its more like $259, same price as the Kindle! I don’t think I could read on my ipod touch tho. I do have the kindle app and use it occasionally, but it isn’t as nice to read from as the Kindle!
Tiff I still think $259 makes me wince and clutch my wallet close to my heart. I’m all about ereaders, but I can’t seem to take the financial plunge yet. Any thoughts about the sony e-reader?
@K.C. Smokinhotbooks, It is definitely a splurge. My kindle was my birthday present last year and it has been well worth it simply because of the sheer number of books I have read since I bought it. Before the kindle I read maybe 6 a year, if that. Consider all the freebies that amazon and other sites give away, the discounted kindle book pricing(most of the time), and if you are tech savvy you can use ebooks from the library…. well it is probably close to breaking even in savings.
I have never tried to read on the sony e-reader but I know a few people who have them and like them just fine. I went with the kindle over the sony because at the time they were similar in price and I really really wanted the wireless book buying the kindle offers.
KV you make me want to take the plunge!